Replaced with actual photo at delivery
| Address | Sale Price | Bed | Bath | Park | Land (m²) | $/m² | Sold | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Miller St, Thornbury | $1,095,000 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 285 | $3,842 | 8 wks ago | 0.1 km |
| 7 Albert St, Thornbury | $1,120,000 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 310 | $3,613 | 10 wks ago | 0.3 km |
| 29 Station St, Thornbury | $1,080,000 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 295 | $3,661 | 12 wks ago | 0.5 km |
| 14 Normanby Ave, Northcote | $1,145,000 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 278 | $4,119 | 14 wks ago | 0.8 km |
| 52 Shaftesbury Pde, Thornbury | $1,055,000 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 291 | $3,625 | 17 wks ago | 0.6 km |
| 3 Tresize St, Northcote | $1,165,000 | 4 | 1 | 1 | 305 | $3,820 | 19 wks ago | 1.1 km |
| 39 Station St, Thornbury | $1,040,000 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 280 | $3,714 | 22 wks ago | 0.5 km |
| 11 Hutton St, Thornbury | $1,110,000 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 298 | $3,725 | 25 wks ago | 0.4 km |
| 42 Miller St — Subject Property | $1,050K–$1,150K | 3 | 1 | 1* | 302 | $3,477–$3,808 | Active | — |
| Scenario | Purchase Price | Weekly Rent | Annual Rent | Gross Yield | Est. Net Yield* |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| If you pay target ($1.045M) | $1,045,000 | $680 | $35,360 | 3.38% | 2.6% |
| At vendor's lower bound ($1.05M) | $1,050,000 | $680 | $35,360 | 3.37% | 2.6% |
| At suburb median ($1.128M) | $1,128,000 | $680 | $35,360 | 3.13% | 2.4% |
| Risk Flag | Category | Rating | Impact | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Extended days on market (52 days vs 31 suburb avg) | Market Signal | ⬤ HIGH | Confirms market has tested and rejected current pricing | Leverage — use to negotiate below asking range |
| Two price reductions since listing ($50K off) | Vendor Behaviour | ⬤ HIGH | Vendor overpriced initially; now catching up to market | Strong negotiating position — open below lower range |
| Single bathroom | Property Attribute | ⬤ MEDIUM | Limits buyer pool at resale; 2-bath commands $50–80K premium in this suburb | Budget $40–60K for bathroom addition if land permits |
| Average property condition — period kitchen/bathroom | Property Condition | ⬤ MEDIUM | Cosmetic renovation required. $50–80K estimate for full update | Factor into offer price. Budget separately pre-purchase |
| Laneway parking only — no secure garage | Property Attribute | ⬤ MEDIUM | Some buyers will exclude at resale. Less secure than lock-up | Check if laneway access can support a garage addition |
| Land size below suburb median (302m² vs ~350m²) | Land Value | ⬤ LOW | Slightly less land per dollar than suburb average | Priced accordingly — offset by strong location attributes |
| Proximity to High St commercial strip (~300m) | Liveability | ⬤ LOW | Minor foot traffic and noise from bars/restaurants on weekends | Visit on a Friday/Saturday night before committing to offer |
| Interest rate environment — RBA in hold/cut cycle | Macro Risk | ⬤ LOW | If rates rise, property values could soften short-term | Strong suburb fundamentals and hold for 5+ years reduces exposure |
- Have you physically accessed the subfloor? What is the ventilation and moisture level?
- Is there any evidence of active termite activity or past termite damage?
- Are there any signs of rising damp in the lower course brickwork — internally and externally?
- What type of electrical wiring is present? Has it been updated, and if so when?
- Are the roof tiles original? What is the condition of the ridge capping and valley iron?
- Is the structural cracking (if any) active or historical? Do I need a structural engineer?
- Are there any visible asbestos-containing materials? Do you recommend a hazmat survey?
- What is your assessment of the drainage? Do you recommend a CCTV drain inspection?
- Comparable sales median is $1,103,750 — but that's the unadjusted pool. Adjusted down for single bathroom (~$40K discount vs 2-bath comps) and laneway parking (~$20K discount) lands at $1,043,750. $1,045,000 is essentially fair market value.
- The vendor has already reduced $50K from their original range. They've signalled flexibility. Opening at $1,020,000 gives them the psychological win of "negotiating up" while you land at a price you're happy with.
- Renovation budget reality: a basic kitchen and bathroom update in Melbourne currently costs $50–80K. You need room to spend that money post-purchase without feeling house-poor. Getting $1,045,000 vs $1,095,000 puts $50K back in your pocket for that work.
- The $1,075,000 walk-away is set at the top of our fair value range. Above this, you're paying a premium the property attributes don't justify. Don't let agent pressure push you past this line.
| Purchase | |
| Purchase price (target offer) | $1,045,000 |
| Purchase subtotal | $1,045,000 |
| Government Duties & Fees | |
| Stamp duty (VIC — investor rate on $1,045,000) | $55,095 |
| Title transfer registration fee | $1,461 |
| Mortgage registration fee | $114 |
| Professional Services | |
| Conveyancing / legal fees | $1,800 |
| Building & pest inspection | $650 |
| CCTV drain inspection (recommended) | $450 |
| Electrical inspection (recommended for 1920s) | $350 |
| Lender valuation fee | $300 |
| Moving & Setup | |
| Removalist (Melbourne metro, 3-bed) | $1,800 |
| Building insurance (first year) | $1,600 |
| Utility connections & misc | $500 |
| Total additional costs | $64,120 |
| TOTAL COST TO KEYS | $1,109,120 |
Important Disclaimer
This report has been prepared by buyerlab., a brand of Nextprop Pty Ltd (ABN XX XXX XXX XXX), for the sole use of the purchasing client identified in this report. All data sourced from CoreLogic RP Data is accurate as at the date of report preparation. Property market conditions may change rapidly — this report reflects conditions as at 14 May 2025.
This report is provided for informational and research purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice, legal advice, or a formal property valuation. buyerlab. analysts are not licensed valuers. The recommended offer range is based on comparable sales analysis and market judgement, and should be considered in conjunction with your own due diligence, building and pest inspection, legal advice, and mortgage broker guidance.
Nextprop Pty Ltd holds a Real Estate Licence in the state of Victoria. This report is confidential and may not be reproduced, distributed, or shared without the written consent of Nextprop Pty Ltd. All dollar amounts are in Australian Dollars (AUD).